Hello, my friends! Here’s the promised comparison of Ivy and Parker (Truly Me #40).
American Girl’s Asian dolls all look pretty similar, and it’s a bit of a shame. Give some of them freckles or side bangs or a different eyebrow shape — just something to make them stand out from each other. Anyway, in this post, I’ll be pointing out the differences between my two lovely Asian AGs.
They both have the Jess face mold, and feathered eyebrows. I feel like Ivy’s skin has a more yellow tone to it than #40’s.
Ivy’s eyes are slightly different from #40’s. Her eyes are decal brown (#40 has the regular brown), and there’s some light brown around them.
They both have dark hair, but Ivy’s is black, and #40’s is brown. Ivy’s hair is parted down the middle, while #40’s is parted on the left side.
Ivy has shoulder-length hair. #40’s goes about an inch and a half past the shoulders.
Styling Ivy’s hair can be quite difficult. It’s too short to do much with, except for pigtails. #40’s hair is long enough to do most hairstyles, although i think a bun would be difficult (but possible).
Since Ivy was retired in 2014 (before the awful zip ties were reintroduced), she has neck strings.
I got #40 in January, 2017, so she has a zip tie. Her head moves pretty easily, though.
And, of course, the main difference between them is that Ivy has bangs.
They’re both beautiful dolls, and I wouldn’t really recommend one over the other. You can do more with #40’s hair, though. And she would be easier to purchase, since, unlike Ivy, American Girl is still selling her.
Which do you like better: Ivy Ling, or Truly Me #40?
xo
Loren
They are so cute! You did it! You got this up before July! Good job! Good job on comparing them and I totally agree that they need to add diversity in their Asian dolls.
Parker’s hair reminds me of Paige’s(#66)
Diamond
worldofagdolls.blogspot.com
LikeLike
yep, i did, i’m so proud of myself. XD yeah, ag’s white dolls are pretty diverse, but their african and asian ones aren’t that different from each other.
oh yeah, you’re right! #66’s hair seems a bit longer, though.
xo loren
LikeLike
I love this! This was very fun to read. I don’t know which one I like better. Their African-American dolls are pretty much the same too.
LikeLike
thank you! yep, the african american dolls definitely need some diversity.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
Totally, Gabrielle McBride, retired Cecile and one of the TM dolls, (don’t remember which one) are like identical.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I definitely love Parker over Ivy. I love the brown, longer hair over the short black hair. I just love everything about Parker. Ivy is quite similar, but Parker,in my opinion, is a cuter version. I love them both but if it were my choice, Parker is the right choice!
~Paige
LikeLike
they’re both pretty, but, yeah, there’s something about parker’s face that’s a little cuter.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like Ivey a little better, because of her bangs. But # 40 is adorable too!
:) Bella / https://dollhabit.wordpress.com/
LikeLike
her bangs do give her a unique look. :)
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
Both are adorable dolls. I wish as well, AG would have more diversity with Asian dolls, maybe one with really long hair! :D Great job as always.
-Rose <3
LikeLike
yep, they are. :) oh yeah, that would be really cool!
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
Gret job on the pictures, and they both look so cute! AG should do a freckled Asian doll! that would be so cool! Or they could also make another Asian face mold, to give it diversity.
LikeLike
Well, there is the Asian mold (aka the #4 mold), but AG never uses it!! It’s a shame, it’s a really cute face mold!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah! I knew about that one, it’s a pity they only used it for #4.
LikeLiked by 1 person
thank you! yeah, i think freckles on one of the asian dolls would be absolutely adorable.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
I would completely die if they did that! It would be so cute!
LikeLiked by 1 person
yeah, me too. :)
xo loren
LikeLike
Great pictures/comparisons!
Another difference between Ivy and #40 is Ivy’s eye cut outs. That’s why they are sometimes considered as 2 different molds: the Ivy mold and the Jess mold.
LikeLike
thank you!
xo loren
LikeLike
Yes, AG needs more diversity. I agree with Alyse, a new Asian mold would be awesome!
I like Ivy better. I love her hair and her bangs! Everything about her, actually! Too bad she’s retired…
Awesome comparison! Really good idea. Keep up the good work! 😃
LikeLike
yeah! maybe a new eye shape would be cool.
thanks! hopefully you can find her on ebay someday.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
That would be really cool!
You’re welcome! Yeah, we’ll see. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
I vote TM #40, but Ivy is super cute too. XD
They are adorable together, I love the last picture. :)
~Ms. AGdoll~
LikeLike
i know, they look so cute together. they could be sisters or cousins or something.
xo loren
LikeLike
An Asian doll with side bangs…*dreams*
I like #40 better, but my favourite Asian doll is #64.
LikeLike
#64 is beautiful. i almost got her instead of parker.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aww, Asian dolls are so cute! I wish I had one. But I don’t think I have much more room for a 12th doll…. Oh well.
I really want Jess or Ivy.
Just curious, what are your thoughts on Z yang?
~Sam <3
LikeLike
i have thirteen dolls, i’m sure you can make room for twelve. ;)
jess is so pretty. i spent a long time looking for her on ebay.
z is cute, and i love all the photography-related things in her collection. but she doesn’t look that different from the other asian dolls.
xo loren
LikeLike
I also have to add that American Girl should try to find diversity in other things besides race. They have never created a girl with karate or golf, but have created 2 Hawaiian dwelling dolls and multiple dancers. 😔
LikeLike
yeah, it’s a bit of a shame, they seem to be running out of ideas for GOTYs.
xo loren
LikeLike
Both of the dolls are adorable! Wow! You actually posted this before July! Great going! Great comparison, and we too agree that all of the Asian dolls look the same.
P.S. Compared to Ivy, Parker’s hair looks really brown, unlike the dark, dark, brown it usually seems like.
❤️,
Tori, Bella, and the dolls
👩🏽👩🏻👩🏼👱🏻♀️👧🏽
LikeLike
yep, i did, i’m so proud of myself. XD
yeah, i thought parker’s hair was a lot darker before i compared it to ivy’s.
xo loren
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Loren! I just started my blog in June of this year! If you’d like, you should check it out!
:) Bella / https://dollhabit.wordpress.com/
LikeLike
They’re both really cute dolls. And sorry for the late comment. I think I like Parker more than Ivy.
LikeLike
I love Ivy. I also have Z, JLY #4 (first version) Jess and Kanani.
LikeLike
Pingback: Updated “The Dolls” Page + Quiz! | happy house of ag
Ivy for sure. :)
LikeLike